Latest News:  

English>>China Society

Hukou system denies right to 'die equal' (2)

By Gui Tao (Xinhua)

09:45, February 06, 2013

The pledge seems a compromise that came out of a high-pressure situation. Such compromises have become more common, although differentiated compensation is still the status quo in China.

It is unknown whether someone with a rural hukou will "die equal" in the next accident.

The difference in compensation has a legal basis that stems from a judicial interpretation on personal injury compensation issued by China's Supreme People's Court that came into effect in 2004.

It stipulates that compensation should be calculated based on the victim's estimated income for the 20 years following his death.

Income figures, however, differ depending on whether one is a resident of a well-off urban area or a destitute rural locale. One's hukou essentially acts as a determinant for the amount of compensation one's relatives can receive.

Debates over the policy's pros and cons have been going on for decades. Advocates say that differentiated compensation is justified, since people in the rural areas earn much less than their urban peers.

But opponents have accused the policy of being prejudiced against rural residents who have long been denied access to social welfare in cities and prevented from enjoying public services such as education, medical care, housing and employment, regardless of how long they may have lived or worked in the city.

The hukou system is quite out of place in today's China, which features much greater mobility than it did 55 years ago, when the system was set up.

It is unfair for someone with a rural hukou to lesser compensation despite toiling in the city for years. His "estimated income for the 20 years following his death" should be the same as his urban counterparts, even if they have a different hukou.

Identity- and entitlement-related differences between rural and urban citizens should be phased out.

In 2010, China's Electoral Law gave the country's rural residents the same voting rights as urban dwellers for the first time by adopting the same ratio of deputies to the represented population in elections of people's congress deputies.

The move represented a significant change regarding differentiated policies under the protection of the hukou system.

The system, which once effectively divided the population into the urban "haves" and the rural "have-nots," is sometimes manipulated by the haves to strengthen their vested interests.

The latest example is the case of Gong Ai'ai, a woman who made headlines after she was accused of purchasing multiple properties with forged identities. A subsequent investigation showed that Gong, who was detained by authorities this week, had four hukou, which is illegal in China.

The outdated hukou system needs reform. If it is too hard to start by providing the rural residents with equal social welfare and public services, start with giving them equal compensation.

【1】 【2】

We Recommend:

Amazing China in 1950s you’ve never seen

People on way home during festival travel rush

A visit to the village of lepers in Yunnan

Beijing fantasy emerges in dense fog

The art of food, the art of life

How much should we pay for family reunion?

China's weekly story (2013.01.21-01.27)

Time to stop appalling food waste

Uncover the myth of 'devil training'

Email|Print|Comments(Editor:HuangJin、Chen Lidan)

Related Reading

Leave your comment0 comments

  1. Name


Selections for you

  1. Navy's ships in antisubmarine training

  2. Servicemen patrol in snowfield

  3. The world in photos (2013.1.28-02.03)

  4. Journeys provide unusual adventures

  5. $16,000 splash to be washed emperor-style

  6. Victims to get equal compensation

  7. Great snakes and the culture behind

  8. Hey, big cosmetics spender

  9. Export woes need for change in trade structure

  10. Boost expected for local cars

Most Popular


  1. Why does US plan to relax immigration policy?
  2. Egypt's relative calm not expected to last for long
  3. East or west, whose home is best?
  4. Dialogue and action can improve Sino-US ties
  5. A long journey that will help all women
  6. An easier ride, but for some only
  7. U.S. further placates Europe while turning to Asia
  8. China's year of challenges
  9. Rice imports not a threat to food security
  10. Getting workers their wages on time

What’s happening in China

Entrepreneur takes 48 buses to go home

  1. 10 sentenced in 'black jail' case
  2. Firework index to reduce pollution
  3. Rail passengers returning thousands of tickets
  4. Organs traffickers sentenced in Guangdong
  5. Police official being probed for fake ID