Japanese PM's election setback could have silver lining

Home>>Opinion

Last updated at: (Beijing Time) Tuesday, November 11, 2003

Japanese PM's election setback could have silver lining

At first glance, Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's reforms looked headed for trouble yesterday after voters weakened his mandate by reducing his coalition's majority.

DISCUSSION

CHINESE

SEND TO FRIEND

At first glance, Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's reforms looked headed for trouble yesterday after voters weakened his mandate by reducing his coalition's majority.

Some analysts, however, said the poor performance by Koizumi's Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) and big gains by the main opposition Democratic Party could be a blessing in disguise for proponents of change.

They said Koizumi's divided LDP - a blend of reformists and conservative foot-draggers - must either embrace reform more fully now, or give way later to the pro-change opposition Democrats.

"We were able to build a foundation to continue reforms under the current structure (coalition), having won a stable majority," a weary but relaxed Koizumi told a news conference.

Koizumi's three-way camp saw its strength in parliament's 480-seat Lower House shrink to 275 seats from 287 after Sunday's general election, while the opposition Democrats took 177, up from 137, the unofficial count showed.

In a sign that the popular Koizumi's personal magic had faded, the LDP failed to keep the majority it had held on its own, although yesterday three independents said they would join, bringing the total to 240, and another six may follow suit.

Koizumi seems certain to remain premier when the Lower House convenes, probably next week.

He also said the present cabinet lineup would not change.

But several analysts were quick to predict that his reform agenda of reduced public spending, privatisation and cures for the nation's ailing banks faced rough going.

"He won't be able to push ahead with his reforms at full speed now," said Tokyo University Professor Ikuo Kabashima.

The LDP had hoped Koizumi's popularity plus signs of an economic recovery would translate into a decisive win.

Some investors in Japan's stock market feared the LDP's limp performance meant reforms would stumble. The Tokyo market's main indices fell over 1 per cent by the end of trade.

More reform, or less?

Others begged to differ, arguing that Koizumi's LDP critics would hesitate to attack him for fear of driving even more voters to the Democrats before an Upper House election expected in mid-2004.

"For Koizumi, the message is clear: talk doesn't work," said Jesper Koll, chief economist at Merrill Lynch in Tokyo.

"I don't believe the anti-reform group will become more vocal. I think it's good for reform, not bad," he added.

Jiro Yamaguchi, a professor at Hokkaido University in northern Japan, agreed that voters wanted change, but questioned whether the LDP could provide it.

"Koizumi's leadership may decline within the LDP, but there is a consensus among the people that there must be reforms to break the old systems... There is no going back to the old ways of pork-barrel politics," he said.

A godsend for the LDP after its support sank under his wildly unpopular predecessor, the media-savvy Koizumi, 61, sprang to power in 2001 on a wave of public support for his reforms. But the lion-maned leader has had a mixed record when it comes to matching words with action.

Pictures of a grim-faced Koizumi were splashed across the front pages of Japan's leading newspapers, twinned with the beaming face of Democrat leader Naoto Kan.

A tired Kan, 57, conceded before dawn yesterday that the ruling camp had prevailed numerically.

He vowed, however, to keep working to take power.

"As the biggest opposition party, we will strive to build a responsible party capable of governing," said Kan, his voice hoarse from the 12-day campaign.

Two party system

The Democrats deployed a pro-reform policy manifesto including pledges to slash public spending and take policy out of the grip of bureaucrats to try to persuade voters to give their novice party a chance.

The election puts Japan on track to a true two-party system after decades of what in effect was one-party rule by the LDP.

Small parties on both the left and right were decimated.

The exception was the New Komeito, the larger of the LDP's two coalition partners, which increased its seats by three to 34. It is vital to ensuring a comfortable majority for the ruling bloc.

Questions?Comments? Click here

Japan PM under pressure after disappointing poll

Ruling coalition wins Japanese lower house election

Is English invading Chinese culture? ( 20 Messages)

Chinese fleet visit heart of US forces in the Pacific ( 15 Messages)

Global survey: Chinese women sexiest ( 56 Messages)

Economist: China has no need to worry about possible trade deficits ( 3 Messages)

Japanese students, teacher make apology in Xi'an ( 17 Messages)

China expects to see trade deficit in near future: official ( 9 Messages)