Latest News:  
Beijing   Overcast/Moderate rain    9 / 12 ℃  City Forecast

English>>Foreign Affairs

San Francisco treaty doesn't help Japan

By Zhong Sheng (Global Times)

10:05, October 25, 2012

In the current Diaoyu Islands dispute, Japan has avoided talking about the Cairo Declaration and the Potsdam Declaration, which set the world order after World War II.

But meanwhile, it resorted to the Treaty of San Francisco signed in 1951, claiming that the Diaoyu Islands are not included in the territory that article two of the treaty requires Japan to renounce. It claimed that the Diaoyu Islands fit under article three of the treaty, covering areas under the administration of the US, while the US returned the islands to Japan under the Return of Okinawa Agreement.

The Treaty of San Francisco will not help Japan. It is widely known that this treaty was signed amid the Cold War between Japan and the Western allies of World War II. It excluded the Soviet Union and China, which had contributed greatly to victory in the war.

Many parts of the treaty did not accord with the Cairo Declaration and the Potsdam Declaration. China has stated clearly that the Treaty of San Francisco is illegal and invalid.

Next, even according to the Treaty of San Francisco, we can hardly draw the conclusion that the Diaoyu Islands belong to Japan. Article two of the treaty states that "Japan renounces all right, title and claim to Formosa and the Pescadores." Here Formosa definitely included the Diaoyu Islands.

Meanwhile, article three only roughly mentioned that the areas considered part of Japan were south of 29 degree north latitude. It didn't mention the Diaoyu Islands specifically.

In 1971 when the US "returned" the "administrative power" of the islands to Japan, it publicly announced that it took no side in the territorial dispute over the islands between China and Japan.


【1】 【2】

Most viewed commentaries
Most viewed commentaries
U.S. should pay more attention to domestic affairs China should participate more in making int'l rules China bashing: Shame on American politics
Face up to temporary tension between China, Japan China, Japan and S. Korea must eye the best despite disputes Japan interferes with Chinese navy's training

Email|Print|Comments(Editor:姚春、叶欣)

Related Reading

Leave your comment0 comments

  1. Name

  

Selections for you


  1. Ammunition support training

  2. China makes mine-sweeping efforts

  3. Spectacular shows in Thai Festival

  4. Classic cars, sexy girls highlight auto show

  5. Top 10 self-made businesswomen

  6. China's economy has bottomed out

  7. China and France to protect freshwater lake

  8. Monarch butterfly

Most Popular

Opinions

  1. Environment anger shows need for reform
  2. Sino-US relations tainted by falsehood
  3. Foreign funding only short-term fix
  4. China's slowdown 'beneficial'
  5. China's development benefits all: U.S. city official
  6. Vested interests must not prevent gaokao reform
  7. Economic strains put Hollande on back foot
  8. Sino-Cambodian ties undimmed by Sihanouk’s death
  9. US should engage Asia as a partner
  10. US risks losing neutrality over Diaoyu

What’s happening in China

Civil service test applications surge

  1. Bank of China in New York sued by terror victims
  2. Applicants for welfare to face tougher scrutiny
  3. Grad school graduates applying for menial jobs
  4. Most Android users not interested in iPhones
  5. More than 7,600 applicants compete for one job