Latest News:  
Beijing   Sunny/Cloudy    27 / 15 ℃  City Forecast

Home>>China Society

Yang Rui was insensitive, but shouldn't be sacked

By Shan Renping (Global Times)

08:23, May 23, 2012

A post put on his Sina Weibo account last Wednesday by Yang Rui, the well-known host of Dialogue, an English-language CCTV program, has caused great controversy.

Yang wrote that the Public Security Bureau must clean up foreign trash, arrest foreign thugs, expose foreign spies, and single out foreign shrews and those demonizing China. An American in China later also posted on Weibo, demanding that CCTV fire Yang. A minority of foreigners in China and some Western media such as the Wall Street Journal supported the demand.

We think Yang's wording was too harsh. He only stressed the problems of illegal immigrants in China without mentioning the contributions other foreigners have made to the country. He slammed many foreigners, which made it a media sensation and led to misunderstanding among foreigners.

As the host of an English-language program, Yang is expected to be more cautious in posting his online messages when presenting his views concerning foreigners in China and avoid expressing them too harshly.

It's understandable that some foreigners have asked CCTV to dismiss Yang. We don't support such a request as it is also harsh and sensationalist. Those who made the request seemed to vent their anger at the Beijing authorities' crackdown on expatriate criminals onto a single person.

Yang posted the message on his personal Weibo account instead of speaking out on his program. It expressed his personal view and feelings and had nothing to do with his job. Currently, Sino Weibo is where the greatest diversity of opinions have been expressed. The way many public figures speak there differs from the way people expect them to. Some writers and scholars often express their views with harsh and abusive words, which happens nowhere else but on Weibo. Yang's controversial message should be perceived against this background. We believe that Yang did not expect his posting to have caused such big waves.

We reiterate that we don't think Yang was right in posting the message as it was, but we think the demand for his dismissal is harsher than his message. CNN host Jack Cafferty made remarks in a TV show in April 2008 that the Chinese people are "basically the same bunch of goons and thugs they've been for the last 50 years." However, CNN didn't dismiss him because of his vile words.

It is hoped that Yang posts his comments with more caution. Other public figures should not behave harshly either. The Beijing authorities' crackdown on illegal immigrants has nothing to do with anti-foreign sentiments. The Chinese public generally holds a kind and friendly view toward foreigners. The authorities' measures are aimed at strengthening social management and will not damage the legal interests of foreigners in China. The anti-foreigner campaigns seen in some Western countries will not be staged in China.


Leave your comment23 comments

  1. Name

Don at 2012-05-30107.6.46.*
Actually the quote from CNN's Cafferty was regarding the Chinese leadership, which he later made clear, not the Chinese people. Yang Rui was just talking about people, no question about that. Yes, he should go.
KHDavis at 2012-05-2959.45.123.*
He and CCTV should have, at the very least, not been so hypocritical and done what they forced CNN and Jack Cafferty to do.... apologize publicly.
jacky at 2012-05-27207.126.93.*
You fired the Russian for putting up his feet..I would say Yang is easily scapegoating foreigners whom in any country are an easy target for the bigger problems that plague a society. I don't care what CNN did since when did CCTV ever judge itself by what CNN did? I do think you need to pull a jerk like yang run off the english channel because I hope whomever sits and is interviewed by him, spits in his face.
Hans Christian at 2012-05-2661.173.107.*
What about the over 40,000 Chinese illegal in the US that have gone through all the courts and are to be deported, but china won't give them passports ?
Tang Wing Ming at 2012-05-26175.137.33.*
I think Yang Rui right to speak.many foriegners just come to China because have no job. They also write and say many bad things about China. These books and there publishers should be banned like In Chinas image. This book just antiChina and antichinese. And western reporters. If they dont like China dont come. We have 8000 year history not like west who really are backward.

Selections for you

  1. Hollywood stuntmen stage trick cycling performance

  2. Miss Bikini International Henan Division crowned

  3. Charm of Chinese gown

  4. Infantrymen in contest

Most Popular


  1. Real benefits of high trade volume remain elusive
  2. Construction boom could hinder economic growth
  3. Much-needed cooling awaits China
  4. Why is Washington so scared of Confucius?
  5. Chance to peacefuly resolve Iranian nuclear issue
  6. What is the US' aim behind arms sales to Taiwan?
  7. Investment-driven growth no longer a viable option
  8. Summit can't stop NATO from being marginalized
  9. Easing liquidity not a cure-all
  10. As Beijing remains mum, trade relationships suffer

What's happening in China

Algal bloom kills millions of abalone in E China

  1. Beijing set to try out VAT starting July 1
  2. Construction stocks soar on policy move
  3. Foreigners provided easier residence registration
  4. Police detain 2 after deadly kindergarten fire
  5. Credit rating stays despite slowdown

China Features

  1. Maritime spat between China and DPRK
  2. The 24 solar terms
  3. High ticket prices, unaffordable landscapes
  4. Huangyan tensions
  5. 2012 Russia-China joint naval exercise

PD Online Data

  1. Spring Festival
  2. Chinese ethnic odyssey
  3. Yangge in Shaanxi
  4. Gaoqiao in Northern China
  5. The drum dance in Ansai