Latest News:  
Beijing   Cloudy/Overcast    0 / 5   City Forecast

People's Daily Online>>Opinion

The signal of Shanghai subway crash

(Global Times)

09:03, September 28, 2011

A subway train in Shanghai rammed into another on Tuesday, injuring 260 people. Reportedly due to a signaling fault, the tragedy resembles the bullet train collision on July 23. Avoiding signaling mistakes is not impossible, therefore these frequent accidents in China apparently show flaws in the signaling system, a system which governs people's lives.

The coal mine safety problem has been a long nightmare for China. No matter how decisively the government vows to tackle the problem, accidents still constantly happen.

The rapid transit system should not follow this track. Increasing speeds should not come at a cost to public security.

The bullet trains were slowed down after the accidents and some lines may even be stopped. This is not the same situation or the subway. If we stop the Shanghai subway, the city's traffic would be paralyzed. In fact, with a passenger capacity of over 10 million people per day, the subway has taken up a key position in the transportation networks of Beijing and Shanghai. China's second-tier cities are also keen on subways nowadays.

However, subway development is confronted with many challenges such as overloading operations and a shortage of trained staff.

Many scholars are complaining that China is building subways too quickly. But when faced with an increasing public demand for subways, whether China could slow down this pace is not easy to answer.

Any absolute conclusions are helpless to China. The security risks that China faces in the long run are much higher than those in Western countries. One of the biggest challenges for China is how to manage these risks.

China should be more cautious and concentrated in avoiding risks. Although this is hard to do, the tragedies in Wenzhou and Shanghai keep reminding people that China cannot afford failure.

Shanghai has already had the appearance of a developed city, but accidents such as the subway collision and the Shanghai fire last November reveal that it is still a developing city at its core.

Many Chinese feel proud that the country's rapidly surging infrastructure could almost compete with those in developed countries. However, the fact that China's city management is backward deserves more attention and caution.

The public's fierce reaction to safety issues indicates that Chinese society has taken Western safety standards as a reference, which is real progress, though not in accordance with China's reality. We cannot complain about public demands being unrealistic. The only option is to try to satisfy these expectations.

We believe Shanghai will investigate the subway accident in the most thorough manner. The safety issue is critical. To ensure the lives of over 20 million people is a grand but painstaking mission, but it is the essence of modernization.


Leave your comment3 comments

  1. Name

ApwsLMjES at 2011-11-29109.230.216.*
These tpocis are so confusing but this helped me get the job done.
kjh2002 at 2011-10-04117.24.78.*
that"s the problem of china investigate the under corruption of bussiness people and thsi is the fault of subway crash train of wenzhou and shanghai
PD User at 2011-09-29202.158.179.*
Given the rapid industrialization of our country, there is an urgent need to train competent operators of the various facilities, including those running the Bullet Trains and subways; operating the nuclear and thermal power stations, the high voltage power systems and all types of large scale industrial facilities where safety must be given top priority. To meet the need for training operators able to deal with emergency situations, simulators should be designed and used to simulate difficult operational situations that seldom arise but do actually happen in the long term. A typical example of what I am referring to are the simulators used for training pilots who fly the various models of aircrafts such as Airbus A380, Boeing 787 etc. Given the nature of the two recent accidents which occurred under situations where emergency had to be dealt with, I suspect such simulators might be absent for the training of the operators of the bullet trains and subways systems in our country.

Selections for you

  1. China's refitted aircraft carrier platform sets sail

  2. China's model practices Yoga

  3. First snow falls in Taiyuan, N. China

  4. Chinese shadow puppetry

Most Popular


  1. Chinese still swarm to hard-hit Wall Street
  2. Durban goals must not crack under pressure
  3. Corporate efforts better than govt ad in selling China
  4. Iceland deal hits local firms with dose of cold water
  5. Are Chinese people truly miserable?
  6. Protecting monetary sovereignty
  7. Think competitively
  8. Public anger hits the roof
  9. Zero-sum mentality should be ditched
  10. US expected to contribute to Asian economy

What's happening in China

Aussie black-belt hosts travel show

  1. Chinese fire dragon dance shown in SW China
  2. New home sales see weekly 12.7% fall
  3. First snow falls in Taiyuan, N. China
  4. Pork industry safe: experts
  5. Sales target likely to be beaten

PD Online Data

  1. The lion dance in Guangzhou
  2. The flower fair in Guangzhou
  3. Lion dances pay New Year calls in Guilin
  4. Jiangsu´s special New Year traditions
  5. Hakka traditions in Spring Festival