Latest News:  
Beijing   Cloudy/Sunny    28 / 19   City Forecast


Raising tax threshold a progressive step (2)

(China Daily)

13:51, September 01, 2011

But China needs to pay heed to the lessons of excessively high marginal tax rates levied in the West in the past, which are not productive of revenue, and also tend to discourage incentive and encourage avoidance and evasion of tax.

However, not all will be happy with the changes, because on one hand, many people in rural areas earn less than 2,000 yuan a month anyway, and thus will not benefit from the increase in the threshold, while earners in big cities struggling with costs of housing, transport and general expenses will say that 3,500 yuan is not enough. It is hard to come up with a national threshold which works in a large country with significant rural-urban disparities.

It is not clear that the raising of the threshold will do much to narrow the gap between rural and urban income levels directly and it surely needs an increase in tax on middle-income earners to fund the necessary additional expenditure on rural education and other services to move in that direction.

The current changes are driven more by a need to encourage household consumption by lower- and middle-income earners who benefit overall from the threshold and tax rate changes. China cannot expect exports to become the major source of demand, which they were before the 2008 global financial crisis. Instead, its strategy should be to restructure production to cater for domestic household expenditure.

As many have warned before, this will be far from easy given the strong savings ratio in China, and a policy of lessening the tax burden on the middle class needs to be accompanied by greater social security safety nets and modest encouragement to use credit so that households can feel comfortable with a smaller nest-egg for a rainy day. The latest tax changes alone are not sufficient to have much of an impact.

It can also be argued that the current tax system fails to take into account the burden on single-income families where a second potential earner instead stays at home with young family responsibilities or to take care of aging parents. The number of mouths a salary has to feed will clearly differ and Western taxation systems have at times incorporated a higher tax threshold for a married worker over a single wage earner, and granted child allowances. But changes in the nature of society and family have rendered that an imperfect measure of need.

The authorities are to be congratulated in taking these changes toward an increasingly progressive taxation system in a harmonious society but more needs to be done, and this is only a first step.

The author is director of China Programs at CAPA International Education, a UK- and US-based organization that cooperates with Capital Normal University and Shanghai International Studies University.

【1】 【2】


Leave your comment0 comments

  1. Name


Selections for you

  1. Last day of Chinese railway travel season

  2. Liu Xiang back to Shanghai

  3. Spanish painted red in annual tomato fight

  4. Gnus migrate across Mara River in Kenya

Most Popular


  1. As school opens, do make children happier!
  2. School shutdown couldn't be good-willed
  3. Japan needs foresight in China relations
  4. Tokyo asked to pursue policy consistency
  5. Libya needs its own development path
  6. NATO faces 'catastrophic success' in Libya
  7. China's 'hardware' aid to Africa makes sense
  8. Population bomb ticks to our peril
  9. Fall of Qaddafi poses challenge for China, Russia
  10. Message from Manila as Aquino III visits

What's happening in China

Bodyguards trained to protect the rich

  1. Chinese Muslims celebrate end of Ramadan
  2. Fire burns PetroChina boss
  3. Factory fire sets residential building ablaze
  4. Rules for food safety management in restaurants
  5. Emergency response to fight drought issued

PD Online Data

  1. The Yi ethnic minority
  2. The Salar ethnic minority
  3. The Tu ethnic minority
  4. The Pumi ethnic minority
  5. The Naxi ethnic minority