High import tariffs stirs heated debate

13:48, July 05, 2011      

Email | Print | Subscribe | Comments | Forum 

A clash of opinions over the need to cut import duties on "luxury" goods has broken out between China's financial officials and commercial policymakers.

Spectacular as it is, the ongoing debate has so far done little to boost domestic consumption, a desirable goal that both sides agree on.

Responding to loud public calls for lower taxes on imported goods, the Ministry of Commerce recently told the press that reducing import duties on luxury goods is only "a matter of time" as key ministries have reached general agreement on the issue.

However, no sooner were Chinese consumers celebrating that news than the Ministry of Finance bluntly denied it had agreed to cut the duties on luxury goods.

Citing concerns over its impact on the national coffers as well as the already huge wealth gap in the country, some people from the finance ministry even suggested that such import tariffs should be raised instead.

There is definitely merit in the argument against tariff cuts.

China's import duty, value-added tax and consumption tax on imported goods, including luxury items, reached more than 1.25 trillion yuan ($193 billion) last year, accounting for 30 percent of the central government's fiscal income. The finance officials are obliged to ensure that any change in import tariffs will not make too big a dent in the central government's fiscal revenues.

Besides, tax cuts for imported luxury goods, which, more often than not, are associated with conspicuous consumption, do not sell well in a country facing such huge income disparities.

In theory, financial officials' concerns are fairly justified. Yet, in reality, they have ostensibly failed to take the bigger picture of the national economy into consideration.

【1】 【2】

Source:China Daily
  Weekly review  


  • Do you have anything to say?


Special Coverage
  • Beijing-Shanghai High-Speed Train now in Operation
  • From drought to floods
Major headlines
Editor's Pick
  • Shopping at International Grand Bazaar in Urumqi
  • Hotdog eating contest
  • Brazil ties Venezuela 0-0
  • Senior CPC official speaks in French-Chinese Industrial and Commercial Dinner in Paris
  • Somalians from the south arrive in Mogadishu for food aid
  • Senior official meets with Chinese representatives in Paris
Hot Forum Discussion