In shadow of Bhopal tragedy, Indian gov’t urged to scrap nuclear liability bill

19:26, June 11, 2010      

Email | Print | Subscribe | Comments | Forum 

The recent verdict on the world' s worst industrial disaster, Bhopal gas leak tragedy, which handed out a meager penalty to the convicts, is casting a shadow on the American hope of the Civil Nuclear Liability Bill from being passed in Indian Parliament.

India's main opposition party the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has for the first time asked the government to withdraw the Bill in the wake of the Bhopal gas fiasco verdict.

"We are opposing this (Bill) in parliament," said BJP spokesman Shahnawaz Hussain earlier this week.

The bill is also facing opposition across main political parties.

A trial court in Bhopal, capital of India's central state of Madhya Pradesh, on June 4 sentenced seven officials of former U.S.- based Union Carbide Corporation to two years'imprisonment for criminal negligence in the gas leak. However, they were immediately granted bail. They were also imposed a meager fine of 100,000 rupees (2,000 U.S. dollars).

Anti-nuclear activists and environmentalists are drawing clear parallels with the gas tragedy. They have been criticizing the nature of the bill and accusing it of "protecting the American interest" and ignoring "Indians' rights".

The absence of stringent laws in the country enabled former Union Carbide Company escape criminal liability after the gas leak on Dec. 2 to 3, 1984 killed thousands of lives immediately and in years to follow.

Activists fear the same absence of criminal liability in the bill will let suppliers of nuclear technology and equipment in the U.S. go scratch free in case of a nuclear disaster which would be much bigger and dangerous than the gas leak tragedy.

"The present nuclear agreement with the U.S. is contentious. It ignores the welfare of the nation and overtly protects the suppliers of the technology," accused Karuna Raina, from Greenpeace Foundation.

Uday Kumar, coordinator, National Alliance of Anti-nuclear Movements (NAAM), said the Bill will help the supplier companies to reap the profits from nuclear commerce and investment in India, but if there is an accident they would not be liable to pay any compensation to the victims.

"According to this legislation, if there is an accident in a nuclear power facility, the onus for paying the damages will be on the operator of the facility. In this case on Nuclear Power Corporation of India Ltd. (NPCIL), the operator of the nuclear facilities in the country," said Kumar.

The NPCL, which is a public company, will use the taxpayer's money for compensation whereas foreign suppliers will just pocket the profit and pay nothing.

Another contention anti-nuclear activists have is that the Bill provides a cap of 24 billion rupees by way of damages which is not enough. They say the liability clause is not stringent enough as the Bill does not have the criminal liability clause.

"Even 25 years after the Bhopal tragedy, people are not fully compensated. In case of a nuclear disaster there would be many more people, who will be wiped out, suffer from radiation and wait for treatment for many years," said Kumar.

On June 20, NAAM will protest the bill in the light of the Bhopal Gas tragedy verdict at Koodankulam nuclear power construction site built with the help of Russia in the southern state of Tamil Nadu.

The organization will also conduct a nationwide Nuclear Prohibition Tour on Oct. 2, Mahatma Gandhi's birth anniversary.

Kumar said the very argument that nuclear energy needed to match the fast growth of the country is a sham. It's benefiting a tiny percent of elites in India.

"Real people in India are committing suicide and dying of hunger. To empower people at the grassroots level and to provide energy for growth, energy should be reproduced at a local level. It should be decentralized. Producing electricity at a local level will be more meaningful instead of importing technology and centralizing its production," said Kumar.

India does not need nuclear power and the country has enough resources like solar, wind, hydro to generate clean energy, he added.

Source: Xinhua


  • Do you have anything to say?


Special Coverage
  • Premier Wen Jiabao visits Hungary, Britain, Germany
  • From drought to floods
Major headlines
Editor's Pick
  • Giant red lantern lights up in Tiananmen Square to celebrate the coming National Day on Oct. 1. (Xinhua/Li Xin)
  • A ceremony is held in Taipei, southeast China's Taiwan, on Sept. 28, 2011, to commemorate the 2,562nd birthday of Confucius (551-479 BC), a Chinese thinker, educationist and philosopher. (Xinhua/Wu Ching-teng)
  • The world's first Boeing 787 Dreamliner for delivery arrives at Haneda airport in Tokyo, capital of Japan, on Sept. 28, 2011. The Boeing 787 Dreamliner, whose buyer is All Nippon Airways (ANA), will implement a flight of ANA on Oct. 26 from Tokyo's Narita Airport to Hong Kong in south China. (Xinhua/Ji Chunpeng)
  • A Libyan National Transitional Council (NTC) fighter shows what is believed to be human jawbone found inside a mass grave near Abu Salim prison in Tripoli, Libya, Spet. 27, 2011. The NTC on Sunday said they had found a mass grave containing the bodies of 1,270 people killed by Gaddafi's security forces in a 1996 massacre at Abu Salim prison in southern Tripoli. (Xinhua/Li Muzi)
  • Rescue workers and local residents search for survivors after a building collapsed in old Delhi, India, Sept. 27, 2011. At least 10 people were killed and 35 injured when an old three-storey building collapsed. More than a dozen people are still feared trapped under the debris, police said. (Xinhua/Partha Sarkar)
  • A visitor has flying experience in the windmill castle of Jinshitan National Holiday resort in Dalian, northeast China's Liaoning Province, Sept. 27, 2011. The castle is a 23-meter-high building with 21 meters in diameter. The castle uses wind tunnel to make objects floating in the air. It is the first indoor stadium in China, which enables people to have flying experience. (Xinhua/Zhang Chunlei)
Hot Forum Discussion