Little Christmas cheer for factories

08:14, December 24, 2010      

Email | Print | Subscribe | Comments | Forum 

Christmas is "the most wonderful time of the year", sings crooner Andy Williams in his 1963 hit. Many Chinese manufacturers used to agree - not any more.

After a year of coping with labor shortages, price hikes for raw materials and an appreciation of the renminbi, many companies that make yuletide products are now considering pulling out of the industry.

Almost 60 percent of the world's Christmas products come from China. Yet, while toymakers record healthy profits, factories producing decorations and ornaments say they are struggling.

"If the situation does not improve, we'll definitely want to quit (production)," said Cai Qichang, owner of an arts and crafts company in Shantou, Guangdong province. "The sun is setting on the Christmas product industry (in China) right now."

Exports of festive products from the province actually hit $770 million between January and October 2010, a 3.9-percent year-on-year rise, according to official data.

However, the increase has failed to ensure a merry Christmas for producers.

Roughly 48 percent of all Christmas products exported by China in the first 10 months of this year were made in Guangdong.

"Orders for our hand-crafted Christmas ornaments, dolls and other works did increase slightly this year," said Huang Shaokuang, sales manager at Jiaying Arts and Crafts in Shantou's northern Chenghai district, which is home to more than 3,000 producers.

Yet, despite generating almost 8 million yuan ($1.2 million) in sales, as of October, the company had made no profit.

"Still, we have fulfilled our social duty of feeding our workforce of more than 80 people," said Huang, forcing a smile.

Factories across Chenghai have reported similar experiences, with "many actually running at a loss", added Cai, who is also chairman of the Chenghai Arts and Crafts Association, which is made up of more than 100 small and medium-sized enterprises.

Rising expenses

Profit margins for factories making Christmas products are already paper-thin, ranging from just 2 to 5 percent, according to a recent report by Xinhua News Agency that quoted an unnamed expert with the Chinese Chamber of Commerce for Imports and Exports of Light Industrial Products and Arts and Crafts.

Things have only been made worse by sharp rises in the cost of labor and raw materials.

Take non-woven fabric, the most common material used in festive ornaments and dolls, prices soared from about 8,000 yuan a ton in January to more than 16,000 yuan a ton in October.

"With raw materials making up at least 40 percent of our gross costs, I dare not purchase any non-woven fabric right now. I'm waiting for the price to drop," said Huang, whose company has been producing yuletide ornaments for 18 years.

Many traders are instead looking to buy from manufacturers in East China's Zhejiang province, where supplies are cheaper.

"We're now less competitive, as Shantou is not a source of raw materials," complained Chen Shaoyan, owner of Zheng Chang Long Carton Factory, which has been making yuletide ornaments for 10 years.

However, even in Zhejiang, the so-called "home of fabrics", plants have witnessed staggering price hikes for core ingredients in their products.

"Our gross costs have increased by about 25 percent," said Huang Jili, general manager of Orient Crafts in Ningbo, a city on the province's east coast. "We are feeling the same pressures."

Although the price of raw materials is likely to fall, analysts predict companies will have to deal with labor shortages and rising salary demands for some time to come.

Factories across the Yangtze River and Pearl River deltas - China's two economic powerhouses - have been short on hands since March this year, following the national Spring Festival holidays.

In response, at least 14 provinces and municipalities have raised the minimum wage, including both Guangdong and Zhejiang.

"If my production line is running at full capacity, we need at least 800 workers," said Chen in Shantou. "This year, I had only 200 workers during the peak time."

He said the situation forced his company to reject several orders from clients, resulting in sales falling 30 percent.

"Some manufacturers finished the orders at a loss to maintain the operation and keep their workers," added Chen.

Luo Yonghuang, deputy general manager of Hongfeng Arts and Crafts in Meizhou, Guangdong, complained that even though he raised his workers' wages by 150 percent, the company still experienced a labor shortage.

As most Christmas products are assembled by hand, the industry is extremely reliant on human resources, and a shift toward mechanized operations would be economically unfeasible for most.

Currency changes

If labor and material costs were not enough, the appreciation of the yuan against the United States dollar may be the straw that breaks the back of China's Christmas product manufacturers.

"If the exchange rate appreciates two or three points, I may not accept any orders at all," said Chen.

Huang Shaokuang at Jiaying Arts and Crafts also urged the central government to curb currency appreciation for fear that "exporters may lose confidence to continue in this business".

Frustrated, manufacturers are trying to take control of their own destiny.

To save on costs, Jiaying is planning to use more "economical materials" in its factory, rather than top-class ingredients. It will also make product designs simpler to cut down on labor.

Like other companies, Huang Shaokuang said his is prepared to raise the prices of its products by at least 15 percent in 2011. Quotations will be reset after March in case the yuan appreciates too much, he added.

However, as Chinese manufacturers are low on bargaining power due to the fierce competition, experts say they will eventually have to compromise with foreign buyers.

To improve profits, Yi Xiaozhun, vice-minister of commerce, urged export-oriented factories to innovate with product design and function, as well as increase added value.

Producers of Christmas handicrafts, big and small, have heeded the call and are investing millions into creating new, standout products.

"I spend at least 1 million on developing new designs every year, which has accounted for 5 percent of our total spending some years," said Chen in Shantou.

As Christmas decorations, ornaments and dolls are seasonal, production lines run for only half a year. The rest of the time, most manufacturers are concentrating on designing and producing samples.

However, handicrafts are easily copied and often pirated by traders who attempt to pass off manufacturers' designs as their own. This is not helped by the fact that, for small and medium-sized firms, buying patents for products can be too expensive.

"Only if we get an order of more than $50,000 for a new product will we apply for a patent," said Huang Shaokuang.

Chen complained that, in most cases, manufacturers are paying for the innovation, but not benefiting from it.

Glad tidings

With the potential of more icebergs ahead, many firms are thinking of jumping ship.

"I have been considering transferring to other industries since the beginning of this year," admitted Chen, who said conditions have slowly deteriorated over the last decade.

Huang said Jiaying Arts and Crafts has already started producing toy helicopters to sell to the domestic market.

Despite the turbulence, some big players, like Hongfeng Arts and Crafts, are still flying high, however.

"We completed $15 million worth of orders this year, almost twice as many as in 2009," said deputy general manager Luo, who added that his company's net profit margin is as much as 10 percent higher than the industry average.

The secret to Hongfeng's success has been building a brand recognized by foreign buyers, which has attracted large retailers and has kept annual orders at a healthy level.

Small and medium-sized factories often cannot meet some of the more stringent requirements on quality and environment protection, while retailers are usually unwilling to buy from smaller firms because they are less reliable.

"We increased our added value by providing abundant and various designs and by using different materials," said Luo, whose company has 36 designers, including four from overseas. "It is essential for manufacturers to be courageous, invest huge amounts of money into innovation and protect the intellectual pro-perty by applying for patents."

Orient Crafts in Zhejiang also saw its sales top 100 million yuan in 2010, an increase of 25 percent.

"There is no bad industry, just bad performing companies," said general manager Huang Jili.

By Gao Qihui, China Daily
  • Do you have anything to say?


Special Coverage
  • Focus On China
  • Shanghai World Expo 2010
Major headlines
Editor's Pick
  • Black headed gulls visit Kunming to spend winter
  • Take a train to Lhasa
  • New parking complex to accomodate 169 vehicles
  • Traditional Chinese treatment popular as cold weather comes
  • Great Dickens Christmas Fair in San Francisco
Hot Forum Dicussion