Latest News:  
Beijing   Overcast/Thundershower    31 / 22 ℃  City Forecast

Home>>Education

Have Chinese universities lost their own features?

By Chen PIngyuan (China Youth Daily)

14:01, May 17, 2012

Edited and translated by People's Daily Online

It is easy for domestic colleges and universities to draw on foreign experience, but they can hardly maintain their own characteristics during the process. More than 30 years after the Reform and Opening-up, Chinese academic circles are regressing in terms of independence and confidence, instead of progressing. Five misleading school-running ideas need to be corrected.

The first misleading idea is that domestic colleges and universities must be "geared to international standards." Higher learning institutions in China are imitating their U.S. counterparts slavishly. Science educators have blind faith in Science Citation Index (SCI), and liberal arts educators accord great importance to Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) and Arts & Humanities Citation Index (A&HCI). Furthermore, they also prefer to recruit professors who have studied at a prestigious university in the United States or Europe.

The second misleading idea is that good colleges and universities should merge with each other. College and university mergers have both advantages and disadvantages. It is generally hard for two "strong" colleges or universities to merge, and a forced merger can cause many avoidable problems. Too much internal friction can cost the merged college or university 10 years or even 20 years in adjusting itself. The merger between "strong" and "weak" higher learning institutions is more practical because a good university must have a dominant style. There will be too much internal friction if the merger occurs between two "strong" colleges and universities.

The third misleading idea is that colleges and universities should "learn from others' strengths and overcome their own weaknesses." Admittedly, a college or university cannot make true progress behind closed doors, and must learn from both domestic and foreign famous universities. However, due to various assessment criteria and rankings, domestic colleges and universities have constantly added new majors in the process of "learning from others' strengths and overcoming one's own weaknesses," leading to the disappearance of their own characteristics.

The fourth misleading idea is that colleges and universities must "meet market needs." Every year, China sends state-funded students to foreign business or law schools that offer good career prospects. However, governments and universities should use scholarships to adjust social needs, instead of rewarding students for choosing hot majors. It may be hard for a student of ancient Greek philosophy or literature to land a good job, but he or she should be rewarded since that part of knowledge is essential to human civilization. By the same logic, state-funded international students should be required to study particular majors.

The fifth misleading idea is that colleges and universities should sign as many cooperation agreements with foreign prestigious universities as possible. Frankly speaking, many of these agreements are just empty promises, and are often shelved shortly after they were signed.

Literary scholars have good reason to reject unsuitable foreign standards. Chinese colleges and universities do not have to do exactly what U.S. counterparts do, or to adopt their language or evaluation criteria.

Read the Chinese version: 如何建立中国大学的独立与自信

Email|Print|Comments(Editor:梁军、马茜)

Leave your comment1 comments

  1. Name

Bored Chinese Citizen at 2012-05-2465.95.204.*
Why wouldn"t Chinese colleges and Universities be poor copies of their Western counterparts. Everything else in Chinese society is a second rate copy from the West. Time for China to start thinking and innovating for themselves and maybe add something real to the world community.
  

Selections for you


  1. Urumqi: A nice day in July

  2. Here comes hot summer in E China

  3. 5,300-year-old rare potter figure unearthed

  4. Memory in black and white: Old China

Most Popular

Opinions

  1. China steps up moves in South China Sea
  2. New rules lay foundation for migrant law
  3. Economy on thin ice with suppressed interest rates
  4. China faces long-term regional annoyances
  5. Japan’s space law shift rattles regional nerves
  6. Experts call for an end to dispute over islands
  7. Border conflict laid aside as giants draw closer
  8. Take wait-and-see approach to US sanctions
  9. Money not a panacea for small business problems
  10. 'Global effort needed to fight corruption'

What's happening in China

Three Gorges Dam at full capacity as last generator starts operation

  1. Shandong natives take most seats in reshuffle
  2. MNCs face challenges in China
  3. China's social security funds safe
  4. Chinese girls outperform boys in school
  5. Update of drug list to give doctors more choices

China Features

  1. China will retain a high economic growth
  2. Why Chinese people love luxury goods?
  3. Official puts on airs in prison
  4. Beautiful scenery of Inner Mongolia Grassland
  5. Sharpshooter with excellent skills

PD Online Data

  1. Spring Festival
  2. Chinese ethnic odyssey
  3. Yangge in Shaanxi
  4. Gaoqiao in Northern China
  5. The drum dance in Ansai